Legal Experts Point to One Line in 'Baby Reindeer' as Potential Misstep for Netflix in Lawsuit Case

Entertainment | June 8, 2024, 6:24 a.m.

Fiona Harvey, the alleged inspiration behind the character Martha Scott in the show "Baby Reindeer," has filed a defamation lawsuit against Netflix for $170 million. Entertainment lawyers suggest that Netflix may have misstepped, particularly with the claim that the show is a "true story." Harvey, who denied stalking Richard Gadd (the show's creator), is seeking damages for misrepresentation and emotional distress. While Netflix argues it has the right to tell Gadd's story, Harvey claims the company harmed her reputation and made up damaging lies about her. Despite disclaimers of fictionalization, the lawsuit alleges Harvey is easily identifiable in the show. Experts anticipate a settlement, as recent defamation cases have resulted in significant payouts. Ultimately, the outcome will likely depend on proving whether Netflix knowingly fabricated harmful details about Harvey.