Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree has made gaming history as the highest-rated DLC of all time, according to Metacritic. With a stellar score of 95 from 56 reviews, this expansion is already ranked 36th on Metacritic’s list of the best games ever. A significant achievement, considering the base game holds a score of 96 based on 93 critic reviews. Shadow of the Erdtree has surpassed other renowned FromSoftware DLC releases, such as Dark Souls' Astorias of the Abyss. Critics have praised the expansion as a "sequel-sized sensation," with many claiming it to be even better than the original game. The expansion not only delivers a tighter experience but also impressively doubles the expected length. Elden Ring's success has solidified its place as a top contender in the gaming world.